Movies like My Blue Heaven

Starring Bruce Willis and Matthew Perry, The Whole Nine Yards plays off the comedic tension between a suburban dentist and his new neighbor, who happens to be a former mob hitman. Similar to My Blue Heaven, it blends elements of witness protection and mobster life with lighthearted comedy.

A loan shark and would-be movie producer navigates Hollywood's peculiarities and the underworld in Get Shorty. Fans of My Blue Heaven will appreciate the crime-based humor and John Travolta's performance as the smooth-talking criminal protagonist.

Fans of mobster comedies will undoubtedly get a kick out of Analyze This, which stars Robert De Niro as a mafioso seeking help from a psychiatrist, played by Billy Crystal. The unlikely pairing and resulting therapy sessions provide comedy akin to the humor found in My Blue Heaven.

Johnny Dangerously is a satirical take on gangster films with Michael Keaton playing a nice guy turned infamous criminal. The film's slapstick comedy and 1930s setting will appeal to those who enjoyed the humor and mob backdrop of My Blue Heaven.

Married to the Mob puts a spin on the mafia comedy genre, focusing on the widow of a hitman who tries to escape the mob life. With Michelle Pfeiffer in the lead role, the film shares the comedic undertone and mafia association that make it a good match for fans of My Blue Heaven.

Sylvester Stallone shows his comedic side in Oscar, portraying a gangster who promises his dying father he'll go straight. The combination of a mobster attempting to change his ways and the surrounding family dynamics echo the light-hearted spirit of My Blue Heaven.

Hugh Grant's turn as an Englishman entangled in the mafia after proposing to the daughter of a mobster provides ample humor in Mickey Blue Eyes. Its blend of romantic comedy and mafia mischief shares the charm and lightheartedness that audiences love in My Blue Heaven.

Matthew Broderick and Marlon Brando star in The Freshman, where a young man gets involved with a crime boss who bears a striking resemblance to The Godfather's iconic character. With a mix of crime and quirky comedy, it has the right formula for fans of My Blue Heaven.