Movies Similar to Too Scared to Scream

If you loved Too Scared to Scream, you'll want to check out these movies. Vote for your favorites to help others discover great films!

  • When a Stranger Calls poster

    This suspenseful thriller builds on the classic fear of a home invasion, much like 'Too Scared to Scream.' When a babysitter starts receiving chilling phone calls, the tension escalates into a frightening ordeal that will keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

    #1
  • Prom Night poster

    A high school prom becomes a night of terror in this slasher movie, which should resonate with fans of 'Too Scared to Scream.' With its blend of teen drama and suspenseful horror, 'Prom Night' is a staple in the slasher genre that offers revenge and mystery.

    #2
  • Black Christmas poster

    If the blend of horror and mystery in 'Too Scared to Scream' appealed to you, 'Black Christmas' offers a similarly eerie vibe. A sorority house is plagued by threatening phone calls and violent murders, making for a quintessential slasher film that fans of the genre will appreciate.

    #3
  • The House on Sorority Row poster

    Like 'Too Scared to Scream,' this film focuses on a group of sorority sisters who find themselves targeted by a mysterious killer. It's a classic slasher that combines tension and horror, ideal for fans who relish a good scare with a side of whodunit.

    #4
  • The Prowler poster

    In 'The Prowler,' a killer in World War II-era G.I. gear stalks and murders teens during a graduation dance. It shares the slasher hallmark of a holiday-themed killer with 'Too Scared to Scream,' delivering gory thrills and a suspenseful plot.

    #5
  • Curtains poster

    This Canadian slasher film follows a group of actresses targeted by a masked murderer, echoing the suspenseful and deadly atmosphere found in 'Too Scared to Scream.' The film combines elements of mystery and horror, creating an unnerving tension throughout.

    #6
Don't see a movie you love?
Help others discover movies by suggesting one