Top Mystery shows on Prime Video on May 1, 2025
Ranked by Attention Score, how much attention each show got online that day. Learn more
RankShowAttention Score
Tomorrow's top 10, in your inbox
Free, one email each morning. 1,000+ people get it. See today's email
- 11
Batman: Caped Crusader - 12
The Rig - 13
The Power - 14
The Devil's Hour - 15
Young Sherlock - 16
I Know What You Did Last Summer - 17
Scarpetta - 18
We Were Liars - 19
The Wilds - 20
Utopia - 21
Three Pines - 22
Dead Ringers - 23
The Lost Flowers of Alice Hart - 24
Harlan Coben's Shelter - 25
56 Days - 26
Tell Me Your Secrets - 27
Steal - 28
Paper Girls - 29
The Horror of Dolores Roach - 30
Harlan Coben's Lazarus














