1. The Mentalist
#350 most popular show yesterdayThe Mentalist stars a former psychic who becomes a consultant for the California Bureau of Investigation, using his keen observational skills to solve crimes. It shares similarities with The Irrational in its use of a principal character with unconventional abilities aiding law enforcement.
7 shows like The Mentalist...2. Sherlock
#377 most popular show yesterdaySherlock is a modern-day adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes detective stories. Viewers who enjoy The Irrational's focus on exceptional intellect and unconventional thinking will find Sherlock's brilliant but eccentric problem-solving methods captivating.
7 shows like Sherlock...3. Elementary
#519 most popular show yesterdayElementary provides a contemporary twist on Sherlock Holmes, set in New York City, with Holmes as a recovering addict and consultant to the NYPD. Fans of The Irrational will enjoy the dynamic between the characters and the deductive methods used to solve intricate crimes.
7 shows like Elementary...4. Psych
#539 most popular show yesterdayPsych centers around a consultant for the Santa Barbara Police Department who pretends to be a psychic, while actually relying on his heightened observational skills. This show will charm The Irrational's fans with its blend of comedy, quirky characters, and mystery-solving.
7 shows like Psych...
Shows similar to The Irrational
If you're a fan of The Irrational and are looking for a similar series, here's our curated list of the best related TV shows, sorted by online popularity.
Popularity data updated on February 22, 2025
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/679c7/679c7431c9b3625f8d1f6717fb762d7d54317765" alt="The Irrational image"
Shows like The Irrational
Looking for shows that are like The Irrational? Take a look at these great shows sorted by online popularity today.