Popularity comparison

The Challenge vs American Idol

TV Show Popularity Comparison by Buzz Score

UpdatedJune 5, 2026

By current Buzz Score, The Challenge is the most popular at 1.2, followed by American Idol at 1.2. American Idol has the highest 1-Year Buzz Score at 2.0. The Challenge has the highest Peak Buzz Score at 11.1 during Dec 10, 2020 – Jan 8, 2021.

Current Buzz ScoreJune 4, 2026

The Challenge1.250% · #574 in TV

American Idol1.250% · #575 in TV

1-Year AverageDaily average

The Challenge2.050% · #424 in TV

American Idol2.050% · #419 in TV

Peak Buzz ScoreHighest 30-day average

The Challenge11.162% · #745 in TV · Dec 10, 2020 – Jan 8, 2021

American Idol6.738% · #1,106 in TV · Apr 21 – May 20, 2025

Buzz Score Over Time

Stacked daily Buzz Score