Movies like An American Haunting

The Witch, set in 17th-century New England, is a haunting portrait of a family unraveling within their fears and anxieties, much like the family in An American Haunting. Its emphasis on atmosphere and period detail makes it a similar viewing experience.

The Conjuring delves into the terrifying case files of paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. Much like An American Haunting, this film unearths the unsettling events of a family tormented by dark forces in their secluded farmhouse.

Sinister follows a true-crime writer who discovers a cache of haunting home movies that put his own family in danger. Its grim atmosphere and the supernatural twist will appeal to viewers fascinated by the blend of history and horror in An American Haunting.

The Others features Nicole Kidman as a mother who becomes convinced her house is haunted. Fans of An American Haunting will appreciate the similar setting of a grand, isolated house where the boundaries between the living and the dead are blurred.

Insidious shares the theme of an ominous presence haunting a family. Viewers who enjoyed the haunting tension and the exploration of the supernatural in An American Haunting will likely be drawn into the eerie and otherworldly realm of Insidious.

The Woman in Black revolves around a ghostly figure terrorizing a remote village, much in the vein of An American Haunting's historical and supernatural scares. Its gothic atmosphere and dread-filled storyline make it a compelling watch.

The Amityville Horror, much like An American Haunting, is a chilling tale of a family experiencing disturbing events in their new home, purportedly due to a sinister presence. Based on alleged true events, it's a classic in the haunted house genre.

The Haunting in Connecticut tells a harrowing story of a family who, much like in An American Haunting, finds their home life turned upside down by supernatural forces. Based on a true story, it examines the thin line between reality and the paranormal.