Movies Like Beneath the Darkness

Gone Girl explores the complexities of a modern marriage and media influence when a man's wife goes missing under suspicious circumstances. Much like Beneath the Darkness, this film takes audiences on a psychological journey filled with twists and turns that question the nature of truth and deception.

In Disturbia, a teenager under house arrest becomes convinced his neighbor is a serial killer, leading to a dangerous game of cat and mouse. If you're intrigued by the suburban terror and suspenseful plot of Beneath the Darkness, Disturbia's blend of thriller and mystery elements will keep you on the edge of your seat.

The Gift is a supernatural thriller where personal secrets spill out during a murder investigation. Fans of Beneath the Darkness will find similar plot elements involving the unraveling of a small town's dark secrets, making for an engrossing thriller experience.

Based on a Stephen King novel, Secret Window stars Johnny Depp as a writer accused of plagiarism by a mysterious stranger. The film's enthralling psychological descent and rural suspense share a kinship with the eerie and menacing undertones of Beneath the Darkness.

Joy Ride offers a chilling tale of a prank gone wrong as three travelers find themselves stalked by a vengeful truck driver. Much like Beneath the Darkness, the film creates a sense of paranoia and fear of the unknown that fans of psychological thrillers will appreciate.

Arlington Road tells the story of a college professor who suspects his new neighbors may be involved in terrorism. The film's intense and suspenseful atmosphere, along with its suburban setting, will resonate with viewers who enjoyed the psychological depth and twists in Beneath the Darkness.

In Lakeview Terrace, a couple's dream home becomes their worst nightmare when they clash with their manipulative and domineering neighbor, a LAPD officer. Like Beneath the Darkness, this film explores the terror that comes from those who are supposed to protect and serve, creating a tense and gripping narrative.

This thriller delves into the horror of a family's discovery that their charming and seemingly perfect stepfather might actually be a serial killer. For fans of Beneath the Darkness, The Stepfather presents another disturbing look at the darkness that can hide behind a friendly facade.