Movies like Stay

If the psychological twists of Stay captivated you, Shutter Island will keep you on the edge of your seat. With a similar tone of psychological thriller and the question of reality versus delusion, this movie follows U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels investigating a disappearance from a facility for the criminally insane.

The exploration of time, existence, and personal demons in Donnie Darko echoes the haunting atmosphere of Stay. This cult favorite combines psychological thriller elements with science fiction, creating a thought-provoking and eerie atmosphere.

Exploring the blurred lines between dreams and reality, Inception is a cerebral experience that fans of Stay's mind-bending narrative will appreciate. The story revolves around a complex heist within the subconscious and is driven by intricate plot twists.

For those intrigued by Stay's psychological depth and narrative surprises, Fight Club presents a darkly comic and equally mind-bending journey. It delves into themes of identity, reality, and self-destruction, all wrapped in a plot that's as unpredictable as it is iconic.

Directed by David Lynch, Mulholland Drive's surreal narrative and dreamlike sequences make it a classic that fans of Stay's ambiguous reality will likely enjoy. The film's cryptic storyline invites multiple interpretations, much like the enigmatic journey in Stay.

The Sixth Sense shares with Stay a chilling atmosphere and a stunning twist. The story, about a psychologist helping a young boy who communicates with spirits, will keep viewers guessing until the very end.

Memento's unique narrative structure and psychological depth make it an intriguing follow-up for fans of Stay. It follows a man with short-term memory loss on his quest to solve his wife's murder, questioning the reliability of perception and memory.

The Machinist is a dark and immersive thriller that offers a similarly disorienting experience as Stay. Christian Bale's character suffers from severe insomnia and disturbing events, raising questions about guilt and reality.