The Amityville Horror Cast
The cast of The Amityville Horror including popularity data. Data for May 29, 2025.
Ryan Reynolds
as George Lutz

Portrayed George Lutz in the movie.

#1
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
10,763 Wikipedia views yesterday
Melissa George
as Kathy Lutz

Portrayed Kathy Lutz in the movie.

#5
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
1,151 Wikipedia views yesterday
Jesse James
as Billy Lutz

Portrayed Billy Lutz in the movie.

#3
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
2,394 Wikipedia views yesterday
Jimmy Bennett
as Michael Lutz

Portrayed Michael Lutz in the movie.

#6
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
797 Wikipedia views yesterday
Chloë Grace Moretz
as Chelsea Lutz

Portrayed Chelsea Lutz in the movie.

#2
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
4,193 Wikipedia views yesterday
Rachel Nichols
as Lisa

Portrayed Lisa in the movie.

Philip Baker Hall
as Father Callaway

Portrayed Father Callaway in the movie.

#4
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
1,186 Wikipedia views yesterday
Isabel Conner
as Jodie Defeo

Portrayed Jodie Defeo in the movie.

Brendan Donaldson
as Ronald Defeo
Annabel Armour
as Realtor
Rich Komenich
as Chief of Police
David Gee
as ER Doctor
Danny McCarthy
as Officer Greguski
#7
Most popular actor on The Amityville Horror
116 Wikipedia views yesterday
Nancy Lollar
as Librarian
José Taitano
as Stitch
Lenore Thomas
as Nurse Fuller
Marie Joelyn
as Store Patron
Dorian Kingi
as Scary Leashed Indian
Alan Koeppen
as Paramedic
Ryan Kross
as Restaurant patron
Sam Raysby
as New York State Trooper
Jenny Strubin
as Grocery Cashier
For the best insights and data about The Amityville Horror, visit our main The Amityville Horror page.