Top Mystery Shows on Prime Video Today
Mystery shows on Prime Video ranked by daily Attention Score, Television Stats' measure of online audience engagement, for Saturday, September 12, 2026. Updated daily after each full day of audience activity.
#
Show
Attention ScoreAttention
1
Sterling Point
11.0
2
Neagley
5.4
3
Carrie
5.1
4
The Expanse
2.8
5
Young Sherlock
2.5
6
Scarpetta
2.2
7
Batman: Caped Crusader
1.7
8
Them
1.5
9
Bosch
1.3
10
The Girlfriend
1.3
11
Cross
1.0
12
We Were Liars
1.0
13
56 Days
0.9
14
Steal
0.9
15
The Assassin
0.8
16
The Devil's Hour
0.8
17
The Lost Flowers of Alice Hart
0.7
18
Harlan Coben's Lazarus
0.5
19
The Better Sister
0.5
20
Harlan Coben's Shelter
0.5
21
Countdown
0.5
22
Outer Range
0.4
23
Tales from the Loop
0.4
24
The Rig
0.3
25
Three Pines
0.3
26
Utopia
0.2
27
The Power
0.2
28
The Wilds
0.2
29
Malice
0.2
30
Tell Me Your Secrets
0.2
31
I Know What You Did Last Summer
0.2
32
Dead Ringers
0.2
33
The Horror of Dolores Roach
0.1
34
Paper Girls
0.1
35
Lore
0.1
36
Red Queen
0.1
