Top Mystery shows on Prime Video on May 4, 2026
Ranked by Attention Score, how much attention each show got online that day. Learn more
- 11
The Devil's Hour - 12
Carrie - 13
We Were Liars - 14
Batman: Caped Crusader - 15
Countdown - 16
The Rig - 17
Neagley - 18
The Better Sister - 19
Harlan Coben's Lazarus - 20
Outer Range - 21
Tales from the Loop - 22
Utopia - 23
Malice - 24
The Wilds - 25
The Bondsman - 26
The Lost Flowers of Alice Hart - 27
I Know What You Did Last Summer - 28
Sterling Point - 29
The Power - 30
Harlan Coben's Shelter

















