Top The CW Shows · Past Year
Ranked by 1-Year Buzz Score · Year ending Monday, May 11, 2026
#
Show
1 Year Buzz Score
1
Gilmore Girls
Ended4.6Good
2
Supernatural
Ended4.1Good
3
The Vampire Diaries
Ended3.3Good
4
Smallville
Ended3.2Good
5
America's Next Top Model
Ended2.6Quiet
6
One Tree Hill
Ended2.2Quiet
7
Veronica Mars
Ended2.0Quiet
8
Gossip Girl
Ended1.9Quiet
9
The Flash
Ended1.9Quiet
10
The 100
Ended1.9Quiet
11
Riverdale
Ended1.7Quiet
12
Superman & Lois
Ended1.6Quiet
13
Arrow
Ended1.5Quiet
14
Supergirl
Ended1.4Quiet
15
The Originals
Ended1.3Quiet
16
7th Heaven
Ended1.1Quiet
17
Jane the Virgin
Ended1.1Quiet
18
All American
1.1Quiet
19
Legacies
Ended1.1Quiet
20
DC's Legends of Tomorrow
Ended1.0Quiet
21
Sherlock & Daughter
1.0Quiet
22
Walker
Ended0.9Quiet
23
The Winchesters
Ended0.9Quiet
24
Penn & Teller: Fool Us
0.7Quiet
25
iZombie
Ended0.7Quiet
26
Batwoman
Ended0.7Quiet
27
Dynasty
Ended0.6Quiet
28
DC's Stargirl
Ended0.6Quiet
29
Charmed
Ended0.6Quiet
30
Black Lightning
Ended0.5Quiet
31
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
Ended0.5Quiet
32
Roswell, New Mexico
Ended0.4Quiet
33
Gotham Knights
Ended0.4Quiet
34
61st Street
Ended0.4Quiet
35
Nancy Drew
Ended0.4Quiet
36
The Outpost
Ended0.3Quiet
37
Legends of the Hidden Temple
Ended0.3Quiet
38
In the Dark
Ended0.3Quiet
39
FBoy Island
0.2Quiet
40
Walker Independence
Ended0.2Quiet
41
Katy Keene
Ended0.2Quiet
42
Masters of Illusion
0.2Quiet
43
All American: Homecoming
Ended0.2Quiet
44
Kung Fu
Ended0.2Quiet
45
Pandora
Ended0.1Quiet
46
4400
Ended0.1Quiet
47
Naomi
Ended0.1Quiet
48
The Republic of Sarah
Ended0.1Quiet
49
Tom Swift
Ended0.0Quiet
50
Crime Nation
0.0Quiet
51
The Great American Joke Off
0.0Quiet
52
Mysteries Decoded
0.0Quiet
53
Police 24/7
0.0Quiet
