Shows similar to Fantasy Island

In this series, classic fairy tale characters are reimagined and intertwined in a modern-day town, with memories of their true identities stripped away. Similar to Fantasy Island's thematic use of characters with hidden or transformational backstories, Once Upon a Time provides a rich tapestry of fantastical narratives.

This action-packed series stars Tom Selleck as Thomas Magnum, a private investigator living in Hawaii. Magnum P.I. is infused with mystery and adventure in a tropical paradise setting, akin to Fantasy Island's picturesque backdrop, appealing to fans of the genre with an added bonus of detective narratives.

This science fiction series follows Dr. Sam Beckett as he involuntarily leaps through time, assuming people's identities to correct historical mistakes. Quantum Leap's theme of dramatic transformations and the exploration of diverse human experiences parallels the magical and transformative adventures of Fantasy Island.

Charmed revolves around three sisters who are witches with unique magical powers working together to protect innocent lives from evil forces. The show's mix of supernatural elements and the protagonists' personal lives resonate with Fantasy Island's combination of otherworldly experiences and emotional storylines.