First Kill

This iconic supernatural drama follows Buffy Summers, a young woman chosen to battle against vampires, demons, and other forces of darkness. With its strong female lead and mix of horror and humor, fans of First Kill's blend of adolescent angst and supernatural elements will find much to love here.

Set in the mystical town of Mystic Falls, The Vampire Diaries centers around the lives of two vampire brothers and the human girl they both love. Like First Kill, the show combines vampire lore with romantic and family drama, making it an engaging pick for fans of paranormal romance.

This dark reimagining of Sabrina the Teenage Witch presents a world where witchcraft meets dark fantasy. Fans of First Kill looking for another strong-willed heroine facing both supernatural forces and the trials of young adulthood will find Sabrina's adventures spellbinding.

True Blood focuses on the coexistence of humans and vampires in a small Louisiana town. It offers a more mature twist on vampire narratives, with a strong emphasis on romantic and political intrigue that should captivate those who are engrossed by the adult themes in First Kill.

A spin-off of The Vampire Diaries and The Originals, Legacies follows the next generation of supernatural beings at the Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted. Much like First Kill, it portrays the complications of young love and friendship in a world where supernatural powers are the norm.

Centering on a teenager who gains werewolf abilities, Teen Wolf combines high school drama with supernatural thrills. Audiences who appreciate First Kill for its young adult themes and dark fantasy will find Teen Wolf's mix of myth and teen issues compelling.

Based on The Mortal Instruments series, Shadowhunters follows a young woman who discovers she comes from a long line of human-angel hybrids who hunt demons. Viewers who enjoy the demon-hunting and forbidden love aspects of First Kill might dive into this world of fantasy and romance.

This series revisits the classic tale of Roswell by focusing on the daughter of undocumented immigrants discovering her teenage crush is an alien. With its combination of sci-fi mystery, romance, and the struggle for belonging, it resonates with First Kill's exploration of the supernatural living among us.