Top Mystery Shows
The best mystery shows on Tuesday, December 23, 2025 by online audience engagement.
Rank
Show
Engagement Score
7-Day
History
History
- 1
Stranger Things
50.04Very High - 2
IT: Welcome to Derry
41.9Very High - 3
The Beast in MeEnded16.23High - 4
All Her Fault
13.38Good - 5
Severance
12.53Good - 6
The Chair Company10.05Good - 7
Castle Rock
Ended9.72Moderate - 8
Wednesday9.18Moderate - 9
The White Lotus9.01Moderate - 10
Down Cemetery Road8.34Moderate - 11
Dexter: Resurrection
7.46Moderate - 12
The Night Manager
6.9Moderate - 13
Absentia
Ended6.84Moderate - 14
Mr. Mercedes
Ended6.52Moderate - 15
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
6.1Moderate - 16
The Curse of Oak Island
5.92Moderate - 17
Squid GameEnded5.74Moderate - 18
Elsbeth
5.23Moderate - 19
Black Mirror
5.05Moderate - 20
FROM
4.72Moderate - 21
Poker Face
4.59Moderate - 22
Yellowjackets
4.39Moderate - 23
Watson4.26Moderate - 24
The Hunting Wives4.13Moderate - 25
Twin Peaks
Ended4.12Moderate - 26
Criminal Minds
3.96Moderate - 27
House
Ended3.84Moderate - 28
The BlacklistEnded3.83Moderate - 29
DexterEnded3.77Moderate - 30
Shetland
3.74Moderate - 31
The Day of the Jackal
3.56Moderate - 32
True Detective3.5Moderate - 33
DarkEnded3.25Moderate - 34
The Expanse
Ended3.04Moderate - 35
Dark Winds
2.97Low - 36
Ancient Aliens2.95Low - 37
Tell Me Lies2.91Low - 38
American Horror Story
2.91Low - 39
Supernatural
Ended2.86Low - 40
1899Ended2.8Low - 41
Only Murders in the Building2.8Low - 42
Alice in BorderlandEnded2.76Low - 43
3 Body Problem2.65Low - 44
The GirlfriendEnded2.59Low - 45
The X-FilesEnded2.56Low - 46
Imposters
Ended2.46Low - 47
WaywardEnded2.35Low - 48
The Institute2.33Low - 49
Midsomer Murders
2.25Low - 50
The Closer
Ended2.18Low - 51
The Rainmaker
2.13Low - 52
SherlockEnded2.13Low - 53
BroadchurchEnded2.05Low - 54
Desperate HousewivesEnded1.96Low - 55
NCIS: Los AngelesEnded1.88Low - 56
Star Trek: The Next GenerationSyndicationEnded1.85Low - 57
FringeEnded1.83Low - 58
The Night Agent1.8Low - 59
PreacherEnded1.68Low - 60
Outer Banks1.63Low - 61
Countdown1.52Low - 62
Mare of EasttownEnded1.51Low - 63
Gossip GirlEnded1.49Low - 64
MaliceEnded1.48Low - 65
Black Doves1.45Low - 66
Pretty Little Liars
Ended1.44Low - 67
Miss Scarlet
1.42Low - 68
The Haunting of Hill HouseEnded1.4Low - 69
EvilEnded1.38Low - 70
Station Eleven
Ended1.38Low - 71
Presumed Innocent1.34Low - 72
The Loud House
1.34Low - 73
RiverdaleEnded1.33Low - 74
The MentalistEnded1.33Low - 75
Stranger Things: Tales from '851.31Low - 76
Gravity Falls
Ended1.26Low - 77
Nine Perfect Strangers1.25Low - 78
13 Reasons WhyEnded1.22Low - 79
True BloodEnded1.22Low - 80
ManifestEnded1.21Low - 81
The OutsiderEnded1.2Low - 82
BoschEnded1.19Low - 83
American Gods
Ended1.17Low - 84
The Fall of the House of UsherEnded1.16Low - 85
The Apothecary Diaries
1.15Low - 86
Sharp ObjectsEnded1.13Low - 87
ElementaryEnded1.11Low - 88
The StrainEnded1.11Low - 89
Strike1.1Low - 90
CSI: Crime Scene InvestigationEnded1.08Low - 91
Unforgotten1.03Low - 92
Line of Duty
1.01Low - 93
ThemEnded1.01Low - 94
Midnight MassEnded1Low - 95
Wayward PinesEnded1Low - 96
Death in Paradise0.99Low - 97
The Artist
0.98Low - 98
PsychEnded0.98Low - 99
The Capture0.97Low - 100
Cross0.96Low
