Top Mystery Shows
The best mystery shows on Thursday, April 9, 2026 by buzz score.
Rank
Show
Buzz Score
  1. 1
    Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen poster
    Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen
    Netflix logoEnded
    23.9
    High
  2. 2
    High Potential poster
    High Potential
    ABC logo
    19.1
    Good
  3. 3
    American Horror Story poster
    American Horror Story
    FX logo
    9.4
    Good
  4. 4
    Law & Order: Special Victims Unit poster
    Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
    NBC logo
    9.0
    Good
  5. 5
    Stranger Things poster
    Stranger Things
    Netflix logoEnded
    8.0
    Good
  6. 6
    FROM poster
    FROM
    Epix logoMGM+ logo
    7.9
    Good
  7. 7
    Scarpetta poster
    Scarpetta
    Amazon logo
    6.4
    Good
  8. 8
    Imperfect Women poster
    Imperfect Women
    Apple TV+ logo
    6.3
    Good
  9. 9
    The Blacklist poster
    The Blacklist
    NBC logoEnded
    6.2
    Good
  10. 10
    Detective Hole poster
    Detective Hole
    Netflix logo
    6.1
    Good
  11. 11
    The Night Agent poster
    The Night Agent
    Netflix logo
    5.9
    Good
  12. 12
    Young Sherlock poster
    Young Sherlock
    Amazon logo
    5.7
    Good
  13. 13
    The Capture poster
    The Capture
    BBC One logo
    5.4
    Good
  14. 14
    The Mentalist poster
    The Mentalist
    CBS logoEnded
    4.9
    Good
  15. 15
    Severance poster
    Severance
    Apple TV+ logo
    4.8
    Good
  16. 16
    The White Lotus poster
    The White Lotus
    HBO logo
    4.6
    Good
  17. 17
    Dark Winds poster
    Dark Winds
    AMC logo
    4.5
    Good
  18. 18
    Criminal Minds poster
    Criminal Minds
    CBS logoParamount+ logo
    3.9
    Good
  19. 19
    Supernatural poster
    Supernatural
    The CW logoThe WB logoEnded
    3.5
    Good
  20. 20
    Twin Peaks poster
    Twin Peaks
    ABC logoShowtime logoEnded
    3.5
    Good
  21. 21
    The Last Thing He Told Me poster
    The Last Thing He Told Me
    Apple TV+ logo
    3.4
    Good
  22. 22
    The Copenhagen Test poster
    The Copenhagen Test
    Peacock logo
    3.3
    Good
  23. 23
    The Night Manager poster
    The Night Manager
    BBC One logo
    3.2
    Good
  24. 24
    Dexter poster
    Dexter
    Showtime logoEnded
    3.0
    Quiet
  25. 25
    Black Mirror poster
    Black Mirror
    Netflix logoChannel 4 logo
    2.9
    Quiet
  26. 26
    The Expanse poster
    The Expanse
    Amazon logoSyfy logoEnded
    2.9
    Quiet
  27. 27
    HIS & HERS poster
    HIS & HERS
    Netflix logoEnded
    2.8
    Quiet
  28. 28
    Dark poster
    Dark
    Netflix logoEnded
    2.8
    Quiet
  29. 29
    How to Get to Heaven from Belfast poster
    How to Get to Heaven from Belfast
    Netflix logo
    2.8
    Quiet
  30. 30
    True Detective poster
    True Detective
    HBO logo
    2.7
    Quiet
  31. 31
    Wild Cards poster
    Wild Cards
    CBC Television logo
    2.6
    Quiet
  32. 32
    Fringe poster
    Fringe
    FOX logoEnded
    2.6
    Quiet
  33. 33
    The X-Files poster
    The X-Files
    FOX logoEnded
    2.6
    Quiet
  34. 34
    3 Body Problem poster
    3 Body Problem
    Netflix logo
    2.5
    Quiet
  35. 35
    Elsbeth poster
    Elsbeth
    CBS logo
    2.5
    Quiet
  36. 36
    Desperate Housewives poster
    Desperate Housewives
    ABC logoEnded
    2.4
    Quiet
  37. 37
    Wednesday poster
    Wednesday
    Netflix logo
    2.4
    Quiet
  38. 38
    Under Salt Marsh poster
    Under Salt Marsh
    Sky Atlantic logoSky One logoSky Max logoEnded
    2.4
    Quiet
  39. 39
    The 'Burbs poster
    The 'Burbs
    Peacock logo
    2.4
    Quiet
  40. 40
    Manifest poster
    Manifest
    NBC logoNetflix logoEnded
    2.3
    Quiet
  41. 41
    Yellowjackets poster
    Yellowjackets
    Showtime logoParamount+ with Showtime logo
    2.2
    Quiet
  42. 42
    Only Murders in the Building poster
    Only Murders in the Building
    Hulu logo
    2.2
    Quiet
  43. 43
    Squid Game poster
    Squid Game
    Netflix logoEnded
    2.1
    Quiet
  44. 44
    Tell Me Lies poster
    Tell Me Lies
    Hulu logo
    2.0
    Quiet
  45. 45
    Lost poster
    Lost
    ABC logoEnded
    2.0
    Quiet
  46. 46
    Cross poster
    Cross
    Amazon logo
    2.0
    Quiet
  47. 47
    Grimm poster
    Grimm
    NBC logoEnded
    2.0
    Quiet
  48. 48
    The Curse of Oak Island poster
    The Curse of Oak Island
    History logo
    2.0
    Quiet
  49. 49
    Star Trek: The Next Generation poster
    Star Trek: The Next Generation
    SyndicationEnded
    1.9
    Quiet
  50. 50
    Dexter: Resurrection poster
    Dexter: Resurrection
    Paramount+ with Showtime logo
    1.9
    Quiet
  51. 51
    Wayward poster
    Wayward
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.9
    Quiet
  52. 52
    56 Days poster
    56 Days
    Amazon logoEnded
    1.9
    Quiet
  53. 53
    The Girlfriend poster
    The Girlfriend
    Amazon logoEnded
    1.9
    Quiet
  54. 54
    IT: Welcome to Derry poster
    IT: Welcome to Derry
    HBO logo
    1.8
    Quiet
  55. 55
    Death in Paradise poster
    Death in Paradise
    BBC One logo
    1.8
    Quiet
  56. 56
    Station Eleven poster
    Station Eleven
    HBO Max logoEnded
    1.7
    Quiet
  57. 57
    The Day of the Jackal poster
    The Day of the Jackal
    Sky Atlantic logoSky Showcase logo
    1.7
    Quiet
  58. 58
    NCIS: Los Angeles poster
    NCIS: Los Angeles
    CBS logoEnded
    1.7
    Quiet
  59. 59
    Pretty Little Liars poster
    Pretty Little Liars
    Freeform logoABC Family logoEnded
    1.7
    Quiet
  60. 60
    Gravity Falls poster
    Gravity Falls
    Disney Channel logoDisney XD logoEnded
    1.6
    Quiet
  61. 61
    All Her Fault poster
    All Her Fault
    Sky Atlantic logoEnded
    1.6
    Quiet
  62. 62
    Watson poster
    Watson
    CBS logo
    1.6
    Quiet
  63. 63
    Gossip Girl poster
    Gossip Girl
    The CW logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  64. 64
    Elementary poster
    Elementary
    CBS logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  65. 65
    The Beast in Me poster
    The Beast in Me
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  66. 66
    The Haunting of Hill House poster
    The Haunting of Hill House
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  67. 67
    13 Reasons Why poster
    13 Reasons Why
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  68. 68
    True Blood poster
    True Blood
    HBO logoEnded
    1.5
    Quiet
  69. 69
    Outer Banks poster
    Outer Banks
    Netflix logo
    1.5
    Quiet
  70. 70
    Presumed Innocent poster
    Presumed Innocent
    Apple TV+ logo
    1.5
    Quiet
  71. 71
    Veronica Mars poster
    Veronica Mars
    UPN logoThe CW logoHulu logoEnded
    1.4
    Quiet
  72. 72
    Psych poster
    Psych
    USA Network logoEnded
    1.4
    Quiet
  73. 73
    Poker Face poster
    Poker Face
    Peacock logo
    1.4
    Quiet
  74. 74
    Midsomer Murders poster
    Midsomer Murders
    ITV logo
    1.4
    Quiet
  75. 75
    Sherlock poster
    Sherlock
    BBC One logoEnded
    1.4
    Quiet
  76. 76
    Riverdale poster
    Riverdale
    The CW logoEnded
    1.3
    Quiet
  77. 77
    PONIES poster
    PONIES
    Peacock logo
    1.3
    Quiet
  78. 78
    Midnight Mass poster
    Midnight Mass
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.3
    Quiet
  79. 79
    Dept. Q poster
    Dept. Q
    Netflix logo
    1.3
    Quiet
  80. 80
    The Hunting Wives poster
    The Hunting Wives
    Netflix logo
    1.2
    Quiet
  81. 81
    Agatha Christie's Seven Dials poster
    Agatha Christie's Seven Dials
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  82. 82
    Bosch poster
    Bosch
    Amazon logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  83. 83
    Mr. Mercedes poster
    Mr. Mercedes
    Audience logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  84. 84
    The Originals poster
    The Originals
    The CW logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  85. 85
    The Devil's Hour poster
    The Devil's Hour
    Amazon logo
    1.2
    Quiet
  86. 86
    Alice in Borderland poster
    Alice in Borderland
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  87. 87
    Run Away poster
    Run Away
    Netflix logoEnded
    1.2
    Quiet
  88. 88
    Rizzoli & Isles poster
    Rizzoli & Isles
    TNT logoEnded
    1.1
    Quiet
  89. 89
    Small Prophets poster
    Small Prophets
    BBC Two logo
    1.1
    Quiet
  90. 90
    The Strain poster
    The Strain
    FX logoEnded
    1.1
    Quiet
  91. 91
    Spider-Noir poster
    Spider-Noir
    MGM+ logo
    1.1
    Quiet
  92. 92
    Shetland poster
    Shetland
    BBC One logoBBC Four logo
    1.1
    Quiet
  93. 93
    White Collar poster
    White Collar
    USA Network logoEnded
    1.1
    Quiet
  94. 94
    Death Note poster
    Death Note
    Nippon TV logoEnded
    1.1
    Quiet
  95. 95
    Ancient Aliens poster
    Ancient Aliens
    History logo
    1.1
    Quiet
  96. 96
    Sharp Objects poster
    Sharp Objects
    HBO logoEnded
    1.0
    Quiet
  97. 97
    Absentia poster
    Absentia
    Amazon logoAXN logoEnded
    1.0
    Quiet
  98. 98
    Stranger Things: Tales from '85 poster
    Stranger Things: Tales from '85
    Netflix logo
    1.0
    Quiet
  99. 99
    Monk poster
    Monk
    USA Network logoEnded
    1.0
    Quiet
  100. 100
    Broadchurch poster
    Broadchurch
    ITV logoEnded
    1.0
    Quiet