Top Mystery TV Shows of the Past Year
Ranked by 1-Year Attention Score, Television Stats' measure of online audience engagement across the last 365 days, for the year ending Sunday, September 20, 2026.
#
Show
1-Year Attention Score1-Yr Attention
1
Stranger Things
Ended32.6
2
IT: Welcome to Derry
18.1
3
Widow's Bay
15.4
4
Slow Horses
New 5d ago11.8
5
FROM
10.8
6
The Night Manager
10.7
7
The Beast in Me
Ended10.7
8
Spider-Noir
Ended9.5
9
I Will Find You
Ended9.4
10
HIS & HERS
Ended9.0
11
Lanterns
8.9
12
All Her Fault
Ended8.7
13
Severance
8.6
14
Wayward
Ended7.3
15
High Potential
7.2
16
The White Lotus
7.0
17
Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen
Ended6.8
18
The Boroughs
Ended6.1
19
The Night Agent
6.1
20
DTF St. Louis
6.1
21
Wednesday
6.0
22
American Horror Story
5.8
23
Run Away
Ended5.6
24
Twin Peaks
Ended5.5
25
Tell Me Lies
Ended5.4
26
Dexter
Ended5.4
27
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
5.3
28
Scarpetta
5.2
29
Dark
Ended5.1
30
The Chair Company
4.8
31
Only Murders in the Building
4.8
32
Young Sherlock
4.7
33
The Mentalist
Ended4.6
34
Absentia
Ended4.6
35
True Detective
4.5
36
Dark Winds
4.5
37
Supernatural
Ended4.4
38
Alice in Borderland
Ended4.2
39
Agatha Christie's Seven Dials
Ended4.2
40
The Girlfriend
Ended4.2
41
Black Mirror
4.1
42
3 Body Problem
4.0
43
The X-Files
Ended3.9
44
Criminal Minds
3.9
45
Down Cemetery Road
3.8
46
Yellowjackets
3.8
47
Mr. Mercedes
Ended3.7
48
Desperate Housewives
Ended3.7
49
Squid Game
Ended3.6
50
Dexter: Resurrection
3.6
51
The Day of the Jackal
3.6
52
The Hunting Wives
3.6
53
The Blacklist
Ended3.6
54
How to Get to Heaven from Belfast
Ended3.5
55
Sterling Point
3.5
56
The Capture
3.3
57
Outer Banks
Ended3.3
58
56 Days
Ended3.1
59
Lost
Ended3.0
60
Dept. Q
3.0
61
The Shards
3.0
62
The Expanse
Ended3.0
63
Death in Paradise
2.8
64
The Haunting of Hill House
Ended2.7
65
Sherlock
Ended2.7
66
The Agency
2.6
67
You
Ended2.6
68
Mare of Easttown
2.5
69
Cross
2.5
70
Stranger Things: Tales from '85
New 4d ago2.5
71
Small Prophets
2.5
72
The Last Thing He Told Me
2.5
73
Shetland
2.5
74
Under Salt Marsh
Ended2.4
75
The Terror
Ended2.3
76
Star Trek: The Next Generation
2.3
77
The 'Burbs
2.3
78
Midsomer Murders
2.3
79
Sharp Objects
2.3
80
Midnight Mass
Ended2.3
81
13 Reasons Why
Ended2.3
82
Sugar
2.3
83
Veronica Mars
Ended2.2
84
Broadchurch
Ended2.2
85
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
2.2
86
Evil
Ended2.2
87
Behind Her Eyes
Ended2.2
88
Castle Rock
Ended2.1
89
Imperfect Women
Ended2.1
90
The Outsider
2.0
91
The Fall of the House of Usher
Ended2.0
92
Watson
Ended2.0
93
Manifest
Ended1.9
94
True Blood
1.9
95
Gravity Falls
Ended1.9
96
The Residence
Ended1.9
97
UNTAMED
1.9
98
Detective Hole
1.9
99
The Copenhagen Test
Ended1.8
100
Poker Face
Ended1.8
101
Presumed Innocent
1.8
102
If Wishes Could Kill
Ended1.7
103
Harlan Coben's Lazarus
Ended1.7
104
Fringe
Ended1.7
105
Bosch
Ended1.7
106
WandaVision
Ended1.6
107
Neagley
New 5d ago1.6
108
School Spirits
1.6
109
Riverdale
Ended1.6
110
Steal
Ended1.6
111
Station Eleven
Ended1.6
112
Pretty Little Liars
Ended1.6
113
Wayward Pines
Ended1.6
114
Malice
Ended1.6
115
Batman: Caped Crusader
1.5
116
The Rainmaker
1.5
117
Black Doves
1.5
118
Fool Me Once
Ended1.5
119
Line of Duty
1.5
120
Dexter: Original Sin
Ended1.5
121
Strike
1.5
122
Rizzoli & Isles
Ended1.4
123
Grimm
Ended1.4
124
The Curse of Oak Island
1.4
125
Moon Knight
Ended1.4
126
The Haunting of Bly Manor
Ended1.4
127
Red Eye
1.4
128
The Strain
Ended1.4
129
Agatha All Along
Ended1.4
130
The Closer
Ended1.4
131
Death Note
Ended1.4
132
The Crowded Room
Ended1.4
133
Unforgotten
1.4
134
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
Ended1.4
135
Them
Ended1.4
136
Watchmen
1.3
137
Elementary
Ended1.3
138
R.J. Decker
New 6d ago1.3
139
Vanished
Ended1.3
140
The Perfect Couple
Ended1.3
141
How to Get Away with Murder
Ended1.3
142
The Chestnut Man
Ended1.3
143
The Originals
Ended1.3
144
The Watcher
Ended1.3
145
The Loud House
1.3
146
American Horror Stories
Ended1.2
147
The OA
Ended1.2
148
NCIS: Los Angeles
Ended1.2
149
The Acolyte
Ended1.2
150
American Gods
Ended1.2
151
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
Ended1.2
152
Wild Cards
1.2
153
1899
Ended1.2
154
The East Palace
Ended1.2
155
Happy Valley
Ended1.1
156
Professor T
1.1
157
Ancient Aliens
1.1
158
We Were Liars
1.1
159
Monk
Ended1.1
160
White Collar
Ended1.1
161
Lupin
1.1
162
Homicide: Life on the Street
Ended1.1
163
Servant
Ended1.1
164
The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window
Ended1.1
165
Nine Perfect Strangers
1.0
166
Ludwig
1.0
167
Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities
Ended1.0
168
Bates Motel
Ended1.0
169
Countdown
Ended1.0
170
The Stranger
Ended1.0
171
Luther
Ended1.0
172
Penny Dreadful
Ended1.0
173
A Series of Unfortunate Events
Ended1.0
174
Elite
Ended0.9
175
Missing You
Ended0.9
176
The Institute
0.9
177
After the Flood
Ended0.9
178
Vera
Ended0.9
179
Bodyguard
Ended0.9
180
Under the Banner of Heaven
Ended0.9
181
Locke & Key
Ended0.9
182
Lovecraft Country
0.9
183
Miss Scarlet
0.9
184
Prodigal Son
Ended0.9
185
Disclaimer
Ended0.9
186
Chucky
Ended0.9
187
Cruel Summer
Ended0.9
188
Moving
0.8
189
Grotesquerie
Ended0.8
190
The Ark
New 5d ago0.8
191
Big Sky
Ended0.8
192
Cooper & Fry
0.8
193
Phantom Lawyer
Ended0.8
194
Scream Queens
Ended0.8
195
The Midnight Club
Ended0.8
196
Ratched
Ended0.7
197
Bodies
Ended0.7
198
CSI: Miami
Ended0.7
199
Devs
Ended0.7
200
The Twilight Zone
Ended0.7