Shows similar to Midnight Mass

This anthology horror series is a staple for genre enthusiasts. Each season delivers a new setting and story, from a haunted house to an eerie asylum, and more, offering a similar mix of drama and terror that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats like Midnight Mass.

If the theme of religious horror entwined with investigative drama piqued your interest in Midnight Mass, Evil might be your next binge. The series follows a psychologist and a priest-in-training as they explore the Church's backlog of unexplained mysteries, demonic possessions, and other extraordinary occurrences.

Crafted by the same creator, Mike Flanagan, this psychological horror series delves into the eerie events surrounding the Crain family who grew up in what would become the most famous haunted house in America. If the atmospheric storytelling of Midnight Mass gripped you, the rich character development, and hauntingly beautiful narrative of Hill House will not disappoint.

From the mind of M. Night Shyamalan, Servant explores the depths of grief, madness, and paranoia, swinging between psychological horror and supernatural possibilities. The unsettling tone and exploration of faith and loss are akin to the central themes of Midnight Mass.

A follow-up to Hill House, also from Mike Flanagan, Bly Manor offers another intense, atmospheric horror story. Blending Gothic romance and ghostly happenings, this series will satiate those craving the slow burn, emotional depth, and supernatural twists seen in Midnight Mass.

Set in the Stephen King multiverse, Castle Rock combines the mythological scale and intimate character storytelling of King's best-loved works. Fans of Midnight Mass will appreciate the ominous atmosphere and the twisted narrative that spans various timelines and stories.

A dark and richly textured show that weaves through the origins of famous horror figures in Victorian London. Penny Dreadful is brimming with religious overtones, supernatural elements, and philosophical quandaries that fans of Midnight Mass will find captivating.