Shows similar to Sleepy Hollow

American Horror Story's anthology format explores different horror themes and settings each season. Fans of the horror and suspense elements in Sleepy Hollow are likely to appreciate the show's high production values and chilling storylines.

The X-Files is a classic touchstone for paranormal investigation series, delving into cases involving aliens, monsters, and government conspiracies. For those who loved the investigative and supernatural elements in Sleepy Hollow, The X-Files is a must-watch.

Merging the concept of urban fantasy with crime-solving, Lucifer focuses on the Devil himself as he assists the LAPD. Its mix of humor, drama, and supernatural antics provides a tonal crossover that Sleepy Hollow fans can sink their teeth into.

This long-running series follows two brothers as they hunt demons, ghosts, and other supernatural beings. With a similar blend of horror, mythology, and drama, Supernatural offers Sleepy Hollow fans more of the monster-of-the-week format peppered with a significant overarching narrative.

A seminal work in genre television, Buffy the Vampire Slayer combines horror, comedy, and drama as it follows a young woman battling against vampires and other forces of darkness. Its witty dialogue and creature-of-the-week structure make it a perfect follow-up for Sleepy Hollow enthusiasts.

Fans of the supernatural and folklore will feel right at home with Grimm, a series that introduces a homicide detective as he navigates a world filled with mythical creatures. Like Sleepy Hollow, the blend of police procedure and fantasy elements will keep viewers on their toes.

Set in Victorian London, Penny Dreadful brings together classic literary horror characters in a dark and moody setting. Its gothic atmosphere and complex mythology will appeal to anyone who enjoys the rich, historical tapestry and eerie vibe of Sleepy Hollow.