Shows similar to The Girl in the Mirror

This nostalgic trip back to the '80s fuses supernatural elements with coming-of-age storytelling. Its portrayal of a group of friends facing strange phenomena in their small town has a compelling blend of mystery and fantasy that admirers of The Girl in the Mirror's otherworldly aspects will surely appreciate.

This anthology series is known for its unique settings and horror themes that cover everything from hauntings and witches to dystopian futures. Its tone and style vary by season, offering a broad range of horror storytelling that fans of The Girl in the Mirror's supernatural suspense will likely enjoy.

Though it leans more into dystopian scenarios than outright horror, Black Mirror's anthology style delivers thought-provoking and often disturbing visions of technology gone awry. Viewers fascinated by The Girl in the Mirror's tension between the real and unreal will find much to ponder in Black Mirror's social commentaries.

For fans of spine-chilling tales, The Haunting of Hill House offers a perfect blend of psychological and supernatural horror. Centered around a family grappling with the haunting of their childhood home, the intricate storytelling and eerie atmosphere will captivate viewers who enjoy the suspense and dark narrative of The Girl in the Mirror.

Blending science fiction with supernatural mystery, The OA follows a young woman who resurfaces after a lengthy disappearance with newfound abilities and a secret mission. Its enigmatic plot and exploration of other dimensions will resonate with those drawn to The Girl in the Mirror's mystifying narrative.

This anthology crime series delves into the psychology of various protagonists as they attempt to uncover the motives behind their seemingly inexplicable crimes. The Girl in the Mirror fans may find The Sinner's introspective look at its characters' inner demons and the unfolding mysteries particularly gripping.

A contemporary prequel to the classic film Psycho, Bates Motel dives into the complex relationship between a young Norman Bates and his mother. Viewers who appreciate the psychological depth and haunting elements in The Girl in the Mirror might find a similar allure in the dark drama of Bates Motel.

For those who delight in gothic horror, Penny Dreadful weaves together the origin stories of famous horror icons in Victorian London. With its dark, poetic narrative and complex characters, fans of The Girl in the Mirror's atmospheric tension will be drawn to Penny Dreadful's macabre elegance.