Shows similar to Under the Banner of Heaven

Though more darkly comedic, Fargo's anthology format delivers intense crime stories with complex characters in small-town settings, resonating with the atmospheric tension present in Under the Banner of Heaven.

This gritty anthology series delves into the psychological depths of its investigators, much like Under the Banner of Heaven. Its intertwining of personal demons with the intricacies of crime-solving will captivate viewers who appreciate complex narratives and moral ambiguity.

The Sinner is an anthology series that dissects a crime's motivation in each season. Like Under the Banner of Heaven, it intrigues audiences with its focus on the 'why' rather than the 'who' of a criminal investigation.

While Rectify centers on a man released from death row rather than the investigation of a crime, it offers a similarly nuanced portrayal of how faith and morality intersect with the justice system, which viewers of Under the Banner of Heaven may appreciate.