Popularity comparison

Criminal Minds vs American Nightmare

TV Show Popularity Comparison by Buzz Score

UpdatedJune 6, 2026

By current Buzz Score, Criminal Minds is the most popular at 5.4, followed by American Nightmare at 0.3. Criminal Minds has the highest 1-Year Buzz Score at 4.0. American Nightmare has the highest Peak Buzz Score at 12.1 during Jan 22 – Feb 20, 2024.

Current Buzz ScoreJune 5, 2026

Criminal Minds5.495% · #78 in TV

American Nightmare0.35.0% · #1,587 in TV

1-Year AverageDaily average

Criminal Minds4.094% · #165 in TV

American Nightmare0.36.3% · #1,723 in TV

Peak Buzz ScoreHighest 30-day average

Criminal Minds10.647% · #776 in TV · Jan 28 – Feb 26, 2020

American Nightmare12.153% · #699 in TV · Jan 22 – Feb 20, 2024

Buzz Score Over Time

Stacked daily Buzz Score

More comparisons to explore

Criminal Minds vs Law & Order Criminal Minds vs NCIS Criminal Minds vs Blue Bloods