The Sinner vs American Nightmare

Popularity by Buzz Score · Updated July 6, 2026

×The Sinner1.3Buzz Score · #550 in TV

vs

×American Nightmare0.5Buzz Score · #1,245 in TV

+Add

The Sinner is 2.8× more popular than American Nightmare today

	The Sinner	American Nightmare
1-Year AverageDaily average	1.7#503 in TV	0.3#1,734 in TV
Peak Buzz ScoreHighest 30-day average	41.0#170 in TVFeb 6 – Mar 7, 2021	12.1#706 in TVJan 22 – Feb 20, 2024

Buzz Score Over Time

Stacked daily Buzz Score

1W

1M

3M

6M

1Y

Share of all Buzz ScoreThe Sinner83%of all Buzz ScoreAmerican Nightmare17%of all Buzz Score

The Sinner83%

American Nightmare17%

By current Buzz Score, The Sinner is the most popular at 1.3, followed by American Nightmare at 0.5. The Sinner has the highest 1-Year Buzz Score at 1.7. The Sinner has the highest Peak Buzz Score at 41.0 during Feb 6 – Mar 7, 2021.