I Can Only Imagine 2

I Can Only Imagine 2 Cast

32 cast members · 12 with popularity data

Full Cast

Sorted by Buzz Score · May 13, 2026

Milo Ventimiglia

Anjelah Johnson-Reyes

J. Michael Finley

#19,603 overall

#31,280 overall

#33,585 overall

#33,825 overall

#39,040 overall

#43,376 overall

Jake Miles Johnston

Michael 'Big Mike' Bennett

James DeForest Parker

Terrance Hastings

Support Group Leader

televisionstats.com