Cast of The Fantasticks

Joel Grey plays Amos Bellamy, a character who is one half of the feuding fathers in the story.

Brad Sullivan portrays Ben Hucklebee, the other father who is involved in the conflict central to the plot.

Joey McIntyre takes on the role of Matt Hucklebee, a young man in love with Louisa.

Jean Louisa Kelly plays Louisa Bellamy, the daughter who seeks adventure and love.

Barnard Hughes stars as Henry, a character who provides wisdom and commentary throughout the story.

Jonathon Morris plays El Gallo, a mysterious character who guides the lovers on their journey.

Teller takes on the role of Mortimer, a character who adds humor and intrigue to the story.

Arturo Gil plays The Bavarian Baby, contributing to the whimsical elements of the film.

Tony Cox appears as His Assistant, assisting El Gallo in his endeavors.

Victoria Stevens plays Jo Jo, The Chicken Lady, adding unique color to the cast.

Trayne Thomas portrays the Tattooed Man, a character who enhances the fantastical aspect of the film.