The Mothman Prophecies Cast
The cast of The Mothman Prophecies including popularity data. Data for April 18, 2025.
Richard Gere
as John Klein

Portrayed the character John Klein.

#1
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
5,111 Wikipedia views yesterday
Laura Linney
as Connie Mills

Played the role of Connie Mills.

#2
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
2,714 Wikipedia views yesterday
Will Patton
as Gordon Smallwood

Took on the character Gordon Smallwood.

#4
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
1,376 Wikipedia views yesterday
Debra Messing
as Mary Klein

Portrayed the character Mary Klein.

#3
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
2,028 Wikipedia views yesterday
David Eigenberg
as Ed Fleischman

Played the role of Ed Fleischman.

#5
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
1,233 Wikipedia views yesterday
Alan Bates
as Alexander Leek

Took on the character Alexander Leek.

#6
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
803 Wikipedia views yesterday
Lucinda Jenney
as Denise Smallwood

Portrayed the character Denise Smallwood.

#7
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
172 Wikipedia views yesterday
Nesbitt Blaisdell
as Chief Josh Jarrett

Played the role of Chief Josh Jarrett.

Bill Laing
as Indrid Cold
Dan Callahan
as C.J.
Yvonne Erickson
as Dr. McElroy
Tom Stoviak
as Real Estate Agent
Scott Nunnally
as Orderly
Harris Mackenzie
as TV Journalist
Zachary Mott
as Otto
Ann McDonough
as Lucy Griffin
Bob Tracey
as Cyrus Bills
Tom Tully
as Motel Manager
Ron Emanuel
as Washington Post Reporter
Shane Callahan
as Nat Griffin
#9
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
8 Wikipedia views yesterday
Christin Frame
as Holly
Rohn Thomas
as Dr. Williams
#10
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
5 Wikipedia views yesterday
Susan Nicholas
as News Anchor #1
Tim Hartman
as Sonny
Jennifer Martin
as Coffee Shop Cashier
Mark Pellington
as Bartender / Indrid Cold (voice)
Murphy Dunne
as Gov. Rob McCallum
#8
Most popular actor on The Mothman Prophecies
85 Wikipedia views yesterday
Pete Handelman
as Aide #1
Matt Miller
as Aide #2
Josh Braun
as Aide #3
Doug Korstanje
as News Anchor #2
Betsy Zajko
as Tory Pherris
Elizabeth Cazenave
as Bellhop
Sam Nicotero
as Man on Bridge
For the best insights and data about The Mothman Prophecies, visit our main The Mothman Prophecies page.