Shows similar to I Am the Night

A gritty anthology series that delves into police investigations shrouded in the darkness of human nature. Fans of 'I Am the Night' will appreciate its complex narrative, nuanced performances, and themes of mystery and conspiracy.

Each season of this anthology crime series uncovers the 'why' behind a chilling crime, driven by complex characters and shocking twists. It's a match for 'I Am the Night' fans who enjoy a strong narrative with psychological depth.

Set in the 19th century, the series follows a criminal psychologist (alienist), a newspaper illustrator, and a police secretary as they investigate a series of gruesome murders in New York City. Its period setting and psychological examination of crime make it akin to 'I Am the Night'.

A reimagined origin story of the famed defense lawyer, this series set in 1932 Los Angeles offers a gritty, crime-ridden backdrop that 'I Am the Night' viewers will find familiar, along with a compelling central mystery.

A woman returns to her corrupt hometown to investigate her sister's murder, unraveling dark secrets along the way. Its small-town mystery and strong female lead offer a vibe that 'I Am the Night' aficionados might appreciate.