Once Upon a Time in America

Once Upon a Time in America Cast

85 cast members · 31 with popularity data

Most Popular Once Upon a Time in America Cast Members

Jennifer Connelly is currently the most popular Once Upon a Time in America cast member online with a Attention Score of 15.1. 2 of 85 cast members rank in the top 1,000 actors online today. Updated October 14, 2026.

Jennifer Connelly

Jimmy O'Donnell

Elizabeth McGovern

Louise Fletcher

Director of Riverdale Cemetery

William Forsythe

Police Chief Aiello

#11,144 overall

#12,154 overall

#13,652 overall

#13,989 overall

#14,194 overall

#15,276 overall

Darlanne Fluegel

#17,940 overall

Bugsy's Gang (uncredited)

#31,369 overall

#31,726 overall

#31,946 overall

Woman in Puppet Theatre

#31,886 overall

Richard Foronjy

#33,112 overall

Marcia Jean Kurtz

#33,540 overall

Speakeasy Patron (uncredited)

#37,253 overall

#39,648 overall

Young Max / David

#41,604 overall

Scott Schutzman Tiler

#43,114 overall

#46,314 overall

Adorable Old Man

#50,897 overall

#60,618 overall

Frankie Caserta

Margherita Pace

Young Deborah (Double)

Jerry Strivelli

Cemetery Caretaker

Alexander Godfrey

Mounted Policeman

Mounted Policeman #2

Bruce Bahrenburg

Sergeant Halloran

Young Deborah's Friend

Salvatore Billa

Beefy's Thug (uncredited)

Marco Stefanelli

Bugsy's Gang (uncredited)

Bar Room Patron (uncredited)

Chinese Theater Spectator (uncredited)

Francesca Leone

David's Girlfriend (uncredited)

Deborah's Father (uncredited)

Boy in Park (uncredited)

Newspaper Salesman (uncredited)

Nurse (uncredited)

Pimp (uncredited)

Maria Pia Monicelli

Prostitute (uncredited)

Speakeasy Banjo Player (uncredited)

Speakeasy Clarinet Player (uncredited)

Nunzio Giuliani

Speakeasy Drum Player (uncredited)

Speakeasy Percussionist (uncredited)

Speakeasy Trumpet Player (uncredited)

Speakeasy Vocalist (uncredited)

Rossana Canghiari

Speakeasy Patron (uncredited)

Claudio Mancini

Syndacalist (uncredited)

Waiter (uncredited)

televisionstats.com