Shows similar to American Nightmare

Centering around a Miami-based blood splatter expert who moonlights as a serial killer, Dexter offers a morally ambiguous protagonist and gripping narratives. The show delves into the mind of its anti-hero, a journey that should resonate with those captivated by American Nightmare's psychological depth.

With its focus on profiling and anticipating crimes of serial offenders, Criminal Minds offers an ensemble cast that confronts the psychological motivations of America's most terrifying criminals. Fans of the investigative and analytical aspects in American Nightmare will find Criminal Minds fulfilling and insightful.

An anthology series that examines the lives of detectives grappling with complex and often haunting investigations. Each season features a new cast and a new case, delivering a similarly chilling atmosphere that viewers of American Nightmare may appreciate.

This series brings the infamous character Hannibal Lecter to television, providing a stylish and intelligent take on the crime genre. With its focus on the relationship between an FBI profiler and his mentor who is secretly a cannibalistic serial killer, it's bound to enthrall fans of American Nightmare.

An anthology series that examines how and why ordinary people commit brutal crimes. Its in-depth character studies and exploration of the complexities of human nature will resonate with those who enjoy the character-driven stories of American Nightmare.