Top Mystery Movies of the Past Year
Ranked by 1-Year Buzz Score, Television Stats' measure of online audience engagement across the last 365 days, for the year ending May 20, 2026.
#
Movie
1 Year Buzz Score
1
Weapons
36.1High
2
The Housemaid
20.7High
3
Zootopia 2
18.8Good
4
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery
16.8Good
5
Final Destination Bloodlines
11.3Good
6
Scream 7
10.4Good
7
I Know What You Did Last Summer
9.5Good
8
HIM
8.5Good
9
Knives Out
7.1Good
10
Disclosure Day
6.8Good
11
Eyes Wide Shut
6.5Good
12
Psycho
6.4Good
13
The Thursday Murder Club
6.1Good
14
Shutter Island
5.7Good
15
The Batman
5.5Good
16
Until Dawn
5.5Good
17
The Accountant²
5.5Good
18
Lee Cronin's The Mummy
5.3Good
19
The Woman in Cabin 10
5.0Good
20
I Know What You Did Last Summer
4.9Good
Advertisement
21
Hereditary
4.8Good
22
Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery
4.5Good
23
Se7en
4.2Good
24
Honey Don't!
4.2Good
25
Primal Fear
4.2Good
26
Prometheus
4.1Good
27
2001: A Space Odyssey
4.1Good
28
Get Out
4.1Good
29
Mulholland Drive
4.0Good
30
Midsommar
4.0Good
31
Gone Girl
3.8Good
32
It Was Just an Accident
3.8Good
33
The Sixth Sense
3.7Good
34
Fountain of Youth
3.7Good
35
The Wrecking Crew
3.7Good
36
Wind River
3.6Good
37
Return to Silent Hill
3.6Good
38
Longlegs
3.4Good
39
Arrival
3.4Good
40
The Sheep Detectives
3.3Good
41
Donnie Darko
3.3Good
42
Black Bag
3.2Good
43
The Thing
3.2Good
44
Memento
3.1Good
45
Deep Water
3.1Good
46
Drop
3.0Quiet
47
Vanilla Sky
3.0Quiet
48
Mystic River
3.0Quiet
49
Zodiac
2.9Quiet
50
The Blair Witch Project
2.9Quiet
51
Smile 2
2.8Quiet
52
Us
2.8Quiet
53
Citizen Kane
2.8Quiet
54
Backrooms
2.8Quiet
55
Scream
2.7Quiet
56
Shelby Oaks
2.7Quiet
57
The Devil's Advocate
2.7Quiet
58
The Others
2.6Quiet
59
The Hateful Eight
2.6Quiet
60
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
2.6Quiet
61
Blink Twice
2.6Quiet
62
Leave the World Behind
2.6Quiet
63
undertone
2.5Quiet
64
Blue Velvet
2.4Quiet
65
The Maze Runner
2.3Quiet
66
The Exorcist III
2.3Quiet
67
Event Horizon
2.3Quiet
68
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
2.3Quiet
69
Snake Eyes
2.3Quiet
70
Silent Hill
2.2Quiet
71
Sinister
2.2Quiet
72
Gattaca
2.2Quiet
73
The Killing of a Sacred Deer
2.1Quiet
74
Remarkably Bright Creatures
2.1Quiet
75
1408
2.1Quiet
76
Inherent Vice
2.1Quiet
77
Lost Highway
2.0Quiet
78
Vertigo
2.0Quiet
79
Oblivion
2.0Quiet
80
It Follows
2.0Quiet
Advertisement
81
Final Destination 5
1.9Quiet
82
I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
1.9Quiet
83
Scooby-Doo
1.9Quiet
84
L.A. Confidential
1.9Quiet
85
Basic Instinct
1.9Quiet
86
The Cabin in the Woods
1.9Quiet
87
Chinatown
1.9Quiet
88
Saw
1.8Quiet
89
The Watchers
1.8Quiet
90
Another Simple Favor
1.8Quiet
91
The Ring
1.8Quiet
92
Red Eye
1.8Quiet
93
Oldboy
1.8Quiet
94
The Bourne Identity
1.7Quiet
95
Sleepy Hollow
1.7Quiet
96
The Skin I Live In
1.7Quiet
97
Final Destination 2
1.7Quiet
98
Limitless
1.7Quiet
99
What Lies Beneath
1.7Quiet
100
Unbreakable
1.7Quiet
101
Twelve Monkeys
1.7Quiet
102
Changeling
1.7Quiet
103
The Village
1.7Quiet
104
Rear Window
1.7Quiet
105
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
1.6Quiet
106
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me
1.6Quiet
107
Copycat
1.6Quiet
108
Thanksgiving
1.6Quiet
109
The Da Vinci Code
1.6Quiet
110
Scream 4
1.6Quiet
111
Enola Holmes
1.6Quiet
112
The Prestige
1.6Quiet
113
Knock at the Cabin
1.6Quiet
114
Scream 2
1.6Quiet
115
The Final Destination
1.6Quiet
116
A Haunting in Venice
1.6Quiet
117
The Invisible
1.6Quiet
118
Death on the Nile
1.6Quiet
119
Contact
1.5Quiet
120
Final Destination 3
1.5Quiet
121
Immaculate
1.5Quiet
122
Jacob's Ladder
1.5Quiet
123
Opus
1.5Quiet
124
Double Jeopardy
1.5Quiet
125
Saw X
1.5Quiet
126
Werwulf
1.5Quiet
127
All the President's Men
1.4Quiet
128
Scream 3
1.4Quiet
129
Sherlock Holmes
1.4Quiet
130
The Firm
1.4Quiet
131
Exit 8
1.3Quiet
132
Glengarry Glen Ross
1.3Quiet
133
Murder on the Orient Express
1.3Quiet
134
Clue
1.3Quiet
135
Inland Empire
1.3Quiet
136
The Cloverfield Paradox
1.3Quiet
137
Ace Ventura: Pet Detective
1.3Quiet
138
Flightplan
1.3Quiet
139
Psycho Killer
1.3Quiet
140
Ghost Ship
1.3Quiet
141
Gosford Park
1.3Quiet
142
Super 8
1.3Quiet
143
National Treasure
1.3Quiet
144
Paranormal Activity
1.2Quiet
145
Brick
1.2Quiet
146
Wild Things
1.2Quiet
147
The Adventures of Tintin
1.2Quiet
148
The Girl on the Train
1.2Quiet
149
The Conversation
1.2Quiet
150
The Gift
1.2Quiet
151
Mississippi Burning
1.2Quiet
152
Tomorrowland
1.2Quiet
153
The Client
1.1Quiet
154
Inferno
1.1Quiet
155
Dolores Claiborne
1.1Quiet
156
Gone Baby Gone
1.1Quiet
157
Dark City
1.1Quiet
158
Angels & Demons
1.1Quiet
159
Three Days of the Condor
1.1Quiet
160
The Pale Blue Eye
1.1Quiet
161
8MM
1.1Quiet
162
Knowing
1.1Quiet
163
The Bourne Ultimatum
1.1Quiet
164
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
1.1Quiet
165
Bodies Bodies Bodies
1.0Quiet
166
The Outfit
1.0Quiet
167
Happy Death Day
1.0Quiet
168
Case 39
1.0Quiet
169
The Secret of NIMH
1.0Quiet
170
The End of Oak Street
1.0Quiet
171
Disturbia
1.0Quiet
172
The Deep End of the Ocean
1.0Quiet
173
Silent Hill: Revelation 3D
1.0Quiet
174
Premonition
0.9Quiet
175
Enola Holmes 2
0.9Quiet
176
Amistad
0.9Quiet
177
In the Mouth of Madness
0.9Quiet
178
Identity
0.9Quiet
179
Eastern Promises
0.9Quiet
180
Cuckoo
0.9Quiet
181
Hail, Caesar!
0.9Quiet
182
The Ninth Gate
0.9Quiet
183
Reptile
0.9Quiet
184
Chloe
0.9Quiet
185
House of Wax
0.9Quiet
186
Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed
0.9Quiet
187
Holland
0.9Quiet
188
Hypnotic
0.9Quiet
189
Salt
0.9Quiet
190
Winter's Bone
0.8Quiet
191
Kiss the Girls
0.8Quiet
192
The Invasion
0.8Quiet
193
K-19: The Widowmaker
0.8Quiet
194
Don't Say a Word
0.8Quiet
195
In the Line of Fire
0.8Quiet
196
Presumed Innocent
0.8Quiet
197
Videodrome
0.8Quiet
198
The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus
0.8Quiet
199
Birth
0.8Quiet
200
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
0.8Quiet