Mistletoe Murders cast by popularity

62 cast members · 6 main · 3 seasons · 2024–present62 cast members · 3 seasons

Sarah Drew was the most popular cast member online on Nov 18.Sarah Drew was the most popular cast member online on Nov 18.

#245 TV show on Nov 18 Attention Score2.5

Guest stars

One or two episodes

NameRankAttention Score
  1. Catherine Bellas Helen Smiley · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#5,4251.1
  2. Tom Cavanaghas Glenn Shaw · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#6,7000.9
  3. Steve Lundas Marcus Donovan · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#8,6410.6
  4. Katherine Barrellas Piper Hutchins · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#13,1240.4
  5. Benjamin Ayresas Hollis · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#18,8480.2
  6. Gage Munroeas Shayne Leeland · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#22,4020.1
  7. Natalie Brownas Monica Jones · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#24,7370.1
  8. Dani Kindas Lauren Hanson · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#27,5980.1
  9. Neil Croneas Gordon Chalmers · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#30,6850.1
  10. Jamie Thomas Kingas Richard Leeland · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#31,7750.1
  11. Raven Daudaas Debbie Brannigan · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#32,2870.1
  12. Al Mukadamas Jason Romero · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#33,6580.1
  13. Tony Nappoas Reed Donley · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#35,8460.0
  14. Isaac Kragtenas Pete · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#36,0740.0
  15. Arlene Duncanas Vera Van Dorne · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#40,6530.0
  16. Alex Houseas Benny Cresh · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#42,0630.0
  17. Tommie-Amber Pirieas Carrie · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#44,4440.0
  18. Josette Jorgeas Morgan Johnson · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#55,0240.0
  19. Lisa Michelle Corneliusas Agent Bradley · 1 of 18 episode1 ep#57,0300.0
  20. Vivianne Collinsas Nurse · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps#66,0810.0
  21. Benjamin Sutherlandas Fred Johnson · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps
  22. Raphael Grosz-Harveyas Rowen · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps
  23. Zarrin Darnell-Martinas Lizzy · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps
  24. Dianne Aguilaras Anna Chalmers · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps
  25. Ben Sandersas Trent Hadley · 2 of 18 episodes2 eps

The cast, together again

Other titles with the most Mistletoe Murders cast members

Cast questions

Who is the most popular Mistletoe Murders cast member right now?

Sarah Drew is currently the most popular Mistletoe Murders cast member online, with an Attention Score of 2.5 and an overall rank of #2,006 as of November 18, 2026.

How many cast members does Mistletoe Murders have?

Mistletoe Murders has 62 credited cast members. 27 of them have an Attention Score on Television Stats today.

Which Mistletoe Murders cast member has the biggest career high?

Aaron Ashmore has the biggest career high among the Mistletoe Murders cast, an Attention Score of 8.2 over their best 30 days.