Subway Stories

Subway Stories Cast

68 cast members · 33 with popularity data

Full Cast

Sorted by Buzz Score · May 14, 2026

Man Eating (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

Bill Irwin (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Pregnant Girl (segment "Manhattan Miracle")

Michael Rapaport

Jake (segment "The Listeners")

Wheelchair Man (segment "The Red Shoes")

Peter Sarsgaard

Boy No. 1 (segment "Underground")

Tucker (segment "The 5:24")

Old Man (segment "The 5:24")

Belinda (segment "The Listeners")

Fern McDermott (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

Man in Hallway (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

The Girl (segment "Love on the A Train")

Sarita Choudhury

Humera (segment "Honey-Getter")

Wife (segment "Love on the A Train")

Leyla (segment "Underground")

Christine Lahti

Red Shoe Woman (segment "The Red Shoes")

Nicole Ari Parker

Sharon (segment "Honey-Getter")

Jack (segment "Manhattan Miracle")

Vendor (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Writer (segment "The Red Shoes")

Young Girl (segment "The Red Shoes")

#13,260 overall

Boy No. 2 (segment "Underground")

#16,003 overall

Prashant (segment "Honey-Getter")

#16,535 overall

Woman with Flowers (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

#20,881 overall

Israel Horovitz

Older Man (segment "The Listeners")

#23,057 overall

Michael McGlone

John T. (segment "Love on the A Train")

#27,313 overall

Edward (segment "Honey-Getter")

#34,360 overall

Mr. Nervous (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

#35,274 overall

John Ford Noonan

Blanket Man (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

#39,100 overall

Robert W. Castle

Knish Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

#39,838 overall

Homeless Man (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

#48,398 overall

Miracle Old Man (segment "Manhattan Miracle")

#51,982 overall

News Seller (segment "The Red Shoes")

#58,747 overall

Wayne (segment "Underground")

Grandmother (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Knish Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Anthony S. Calypso

Knish Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Musician (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Carl J. Ferrazza

Hot Dog Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Daniel Freedman

Strange Man (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Musician (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Musician (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Musician (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Knish Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Knish Buyer (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Girl Dancing (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Girl Dancing (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Distinguished Rider (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Distinguished Rider (segment "Subway Car from Hell")

Marie Barrientos

Ragged Woman (segment "The Red Shoes")

Shopper (segment "The Red Shoes")

John C. Vennema

Executive (segment "The Red Shoes")

Security Guard (segment "The Red Shoes")

(segment "The Red Shoes")

White Man (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

José Ramón Rosario

Transit Worker (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

Business Woman (segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")

Bruce Smolanoff

Boy No. 3 (segment "Underground")

Boy No. 4 (segment "Underground")

Subway Musician (segment "Underground")

Steven Randazzo

Officer Mulioli (segment "Honey-Getter")

Subway Musician (segment "Honey-Getter")

Sax Player (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

Old News Man (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

Tammi Cubilette

Denise (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

D'Jamila (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

Dorcas (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

Jewish Cantor (segment "Sax Cantor Riff")

televisionstats.com