⭐
Joel McHale (Self - Judge) leads the Is It Cake? cast as the #1,606 ranked actor globally. Cast members below include current popularity rankings where available.
January 7, 2026

Top 10 Cast Members

Ranked by Wikipedia pageviews on January 6, 2026
#1
Joel McHaleas Self - Judge
Rank #1,6063,425 daily views
View Profile →
#2
Chloe Finemanas Self - Judge
Rank #1,7553,206 daily views
View Profile →
#3
King Princessas Self - Judge
Rank #2,8302,196 daily views
View Profile →
#4
Heidi Gardneras Self - Judge
Rank #3,1092,029 daily views
View Profile →
#5
Fortune Feimsteras Self - Judge
Rank #3,5841,798 daily views
View Profile →
#6
Chrishell Stauseas Self - Judge
Rank #3,8991,662 daily views
View Profile →
#7
Kirby Howell-Baptisteas Self - Judge
Rank #4,5001,434 daily views
View Profile →
#8
Brittany Broskias Self - Judge
Rank #4,6051,403 daily views
View Profile →
#9
Chris Reddas Self - Judge
Rank #5,0561,263 daily views
View Profile →
#10
Lauren Lapkusas Herself
Rank #5,2491,206 daily views
View Profile →

Is It Cake? Full Cast

All 36 cast members with rankings based on Wikipedia pageviews
MD
Mikey Day
as Self - Host · 24 eps
Rank #5,9241,056 daily views

Mikey Day is the charismatic host of Is It Cake?

View Profile→
DD
Daym Drops
as Self - Judge · 1 ep

Daym Drops is one of the judges on Is It Cake? His expertise and passion for food add a unique perspective to the show.

View Profile→
FF
Fortune Feimster
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #3,5841,798 daily views

Fortune Feimster brings her comedic talent to the judging panel of Is It Cake?, making the show even more entertaining.

View Profile→
JB
Jason Bolden
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #34,01711 daily views

Jason Bolden, a renowned fashion expert, uses his keen eye for detail to determine if objects are cake or not on Is It Cake?

View Profile→
MY
Michael Yo
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #17,848166 daily views

Michael Yo, a well-known comedian and TV personality, lends his wit and humor to the judging panel of Is It Cake?

View Profile→
CK
Camille Kostek
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #6,379962 daily views

Camille Kostek brings her charm and expertise as a model and television personality to the judging panel of Is It Cake?

View Profile→
CW
Chris Witaske
as Self - Judge · 2 eps
Rank #15,985216 daily views

Chris Witaske, an experienced actor and improviser, uses his creativity and quick thinking to determine if objects are cake or not on Is It Cake?

View Profile→
CP
Courtney Parchman
as Self - Judge · 1 ep

Courtney Parchman, also known as Flame Monroe, brings her unique perspective and humor to the judging panel of Is It Cake?

View Profile→
FM
Finesse Mitchell
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #20,563114 daily views
View Profile→
AC
Arturo Castro
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #9,954518 daily views
View Profile→
RB
Rebecca Black
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #6,355967 daily views
View Profile→
JG
Jon Gabrus
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #16,226208 daily views
View Profile→
TR
Tony Rock
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #12,187368 daily views
View Profile→
KP
King Princess
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #2,8302,196 daily views
View Profile→
LL
Lyric Lewis
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
View Profile→
BB
Brittany Broski
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #4,6051,403 daily views
View Profile→
HG
Heidi Gardner
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #3,1092,029 daily views
View Profile→
DA
Dan Ahdoot
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #24,70564 daily views
View Profile→
KB
Karamo Brown
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #7,450790 daily views
View Profile→
LL
Loni Love
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #14,233276 daily views
View Profile→
BM
Bobby Moynihan
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #6,518936 daily views
View Profile→
CR
Chris Redd
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #5,0561,263 daily views
View Profile→
TT
Taylor Tomlinson
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #6,0011,038 daily views
View Profile→
NS
Nico Santos
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
View Profile→
JM
Joel McHale
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #1,6063,425 daily views
View Profile→
AL
Ally Love
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
View Profile→
CS
Chrishell Stause
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #3,8991,662 daily views
View Profile→
MJ
Maz Jobrani
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #17,619171 daily views
View Profile→
BA
Blake Anderson
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #7,739749 daily views
View Profile→
CF
Chloe Fineman
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #1,7553,206 daily views
View Profile→
KH
Kirby Howell-Baptiste
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
Rank #4,5001,434 daily views
View Profile→
HS
Hester Sunshine
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
View Profile→
RW
Ronnie Woo
as Self - Judge · 1 ep
View Profile→
JP
Jay Pharoah
as Himself · 1 ep
Rank #11,527409 daily views
View Profile→
LH
London Hughes
as Herself · 1 ep
Rank #22,32190 daily views
View Profile→
LL
Lauren Lapkus
as Herself · 1 ep
Rank #5,2491,206 daily views
View Profile→
Is It Cake? Stats
Top Netflix Shows
Top Reality Shows